top of page

Key Lime Pie Lady: Locally Crafted in the Florida Keys

Home: Welcome

Traditional. Handmade. Delicious.

Home: About

Our Retailers

Trading Post Islamorada

Islamorada, MM 82

Marlin Food Store

Tavernier, MM 88

Murray's Market

Summerland Key, MM 24.5

Wynn's Market

Naples, FL

Home: Products

We do not ship.

To answer the most frequently asked question, we unfortunately do not ship.
Our sincerest apologies.

Home: Text

What Our Customers Are Saying

Local ranked the key lime pie lady inside of The Trading Post second only to his grandma. We concur! Perfect graham cracker (non-greasy) crust, excellent filling. Definitely a winner!

This key lime pie is unbelievable!!! I can’t even put words together to describe it. I’m not exaggerating. You need to try this!!! (We bought it from the trading post and ate it in the car)
We called her, and she happily told us her story. She makes the pies from scratch and it shows.

We tried 4 key lime pies while in the keys and this was by far the best!!! Afterwards, we wished we had only had this version as none of the others compared! Perfectly balanced sweet and tart, amazing crust. Absolutely delicious!!!

Home: Testimonials
pie 1_edited.jpg

A Story Worth Hearing

Barbara and Mike had local Islamorada restaurant  from 2009 until 2017 when Irma caused them to close. While deciding their next venture, customers began to call and ask for the desserts from their restaurants, specifically Key Lime Pie.

Home: Image

Get In Touch


Thanks for submitting!

Home: Contact
bottom of page