Who We Are
Barbara and Mike had local Islamorada restaurant from 2009 until 2017 when Irma caused them to close. While deciding their next venture, customers began to call and ask for the desserts from their restaurants, specifically Key Lime Pie.
In 2018, they started making their classic Key Lime Pie. A thick homemade graham cracker crust, our "just enough" tart key lime pie filling, decadent, rich, and creamy sweet whipped topping and "VIOLA." The Key Lime Pie Lady was born.
FAQs
Do you ship?
Unfortunately, we do not ship our products.
Do you cater?
We do not cater, however, we do weddings with desserts. If you are interested please contact us via the contact form.
Where can I get your products?
Please see our 'Find a Vendor' tab on the menu bar to see a full list, with directions, to our various vendors.
What is your best seller?
The classic 10" Whipped Pie is by far our best seller. Individuals come from all over the States to get a taste of our signature pie.
Can I get gluten free?
Yes, but we need 48 hours notice.
How can I inquire about a custom order?
Please message us directly at barbara@keylimepielady.com for any customer orders.